'Conclave' Review

Conclave had its International Premiere at the 2024 Toronto International Film Festival. Focus Features will release it in theaters on October 25.

Saints and sinners live among us, even in the holiest of places. As the old saying goes, it can be impossible to discern between a sheep and a wolf. And as a cardinal puts it within Conclave, no sane man would desire the papacy, and no man that seeks it should deserve it. Now that the pope is unexpectedly dead, several candidates are vying for the most powerful position in the world, one that will wield the lives of billions and thousands of years of precedent. Cardinal Bellini asks if he can keep the pope’s chessboard as a memento, a bold signifier of the game that’s about to be played.

The term that the film gets its title from is what the process of electing a new pope is referred to. Over one hundred cardinals from all over the world converge in the holy home of the Catholic church, each with their own agenda of how the church should be steered. For Cardinal Tedesco (Sergio Castellitto), the church needs to bring back the conservative views of the past. Cardinal Bellini (Stanley Tucci), while reluctant to even be considered for the position, sees an opportunity for a more progressive church that fits with the time. Somewhere along that ideological spectrum sits Cardinal Tremblay (John Lithgow) and Cardinal Adeyemi (Lucian Msamati), both of whom have gathered enough support to be viable candidates.

Appointed to oversee this transitional period is Cardinal Lawrence (Ralph Fiennes), who must balance egos, ambitions, and media scrutiny just as much as his faith that the man most fit to serve God will prevail. He’s practically the producer for an awards show, scurrying around marble corridors as his assistants feed him every bit of news and each cardinal tries to get a peek behind the curtain.

Much of the cast and crew behind this production will likely find themselves attending awards shows through the winter. Director Edward Berger, wildly hot off the success of his adaptation of All Quiet on the Western Front, once again shows a great command of the literary material he inherited. He and editor Nick Emerson keep a slow-burning, yet propulsive energy to the proceedings. Sequences of backdoor politics and revelations of long-buried secrets cumulate into the multiple rounds of official voting. The tension is wound tight enough to cut through steel, with the score from Volker Bertelmann, aka Hauschka, providing the booming layer of intrigue.

Peter Straughan, previously Oscar-nominated for Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy (its director, Tomas Alfredson, serves as a producer on this project), keeps the balance between thrills and social critique just as pristine as it was in Robert Harris’ novel. It doesn’t take a politically inundated American such as myself to see the real-world parallels between parties filled with brash conservatives and reluctant progressives. There are also hints of humor within this deadly serious debate, such as a Cardinal being accused of misconduct denying all wrongdoing while struggling to operate a Keurig machine.

Longstanding acting royalty fill the cast, with the highest laurels going to Fiennes. He maintains a quiet dignity as a web of lies and deceit begins to unspool right in front of him. His faith in the church as an organization is also shaken, largely because of what the eyes and ears of Sister Agnes (Isabella Rossellini) pick up as she remains hidden in plain sight. A little more time devoted to her and Tucci would have been much appreciated, mostly because they make such a meal out of the small portions doled upon them.

For someone who seemed to appear out of nowhere with All Quiet on the Western Front, Berger has quickly strung together two of the finer films of the past few years. Conclave is a soap opera with as much page-turning substance as it has a prestige-like style, perfect for both the faithful and skeptics alike.